Appraisal With No Comparable Sales

Having few recent sales near your house does not by itself stop the appraisal. Fannie Mae and FHA both need at least three closed comparable sales, and Fannie Mae lets the appraiser use older or farther sales if they explain why.

Sales Within 12 Months Preferred Listings Can Add Support Your Home’s Prior Sale Can Count Competing Neighborhoods Allowed Pending Sales In New Projects Sales Within 12 Months Preferred Listings Can Add Support Your Home’s Prior Sale Can Count Competing Neighborhoods Allowed Pending Sales In New Projects
Three Closed Sales Minimum Older Sales Can Be Explained Distant Rural Sales Allowed One Value Appeal Per Appraisal

Quick answer

Saxton Retail Mortgage does, through conventional loans that follow Fannie Mae rules and through FHA loans. Fannie Mae lets the appraiser use older sales or sales from competing neighborhoods when they explain why, while FHA needs at least three sales that settled within 12 months.

Comparable sales rules: programs side by side

How the 2 program rule sets we offer treat a home with few comparable sales.

RuleFannie MaeFHA
Minimum salesAt least three closed salesAt least three sales settled within 12 months
Preferred ageClosed within the last 12 monthsPreferably within the last six months
Sales older than 12 monthsAllowed if the appraiser explains whyOnly as additional sales, with an explanation
Distant sales in rural areasAllowed if credible and explainedAsk us
First sale in a new subdivisionTwo pending sales can replace one closed saleOne sale inside and one outside, when possible
Foreclosure salesAllowed if they are the best availableForeclosure transfer to a lender not valid
Reconsideration of valueLender must have a process; one borrower request per appraisalThe underwriter may request it

Under Fannie Mae, a loan is not eligible when an environmental hazard is so serious or so recently discovered that no comparable market data shows its effect.

How we checked this: We place loans with several lenders. Each rule above comes from the current written guidelines of a program we can place your loan with, or from the agency guide that program follows, checked in October 2026. We do not name the lenders on this page. Guidelines change, so we confirm every rule against your file before you apply.

Where we lend: Saxton Mortgage, LLC, NMLS #1717191, is licensed in 41 states: Alabama, Alaska, Arizona, California, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Florida, Georgia, Hawaii, Idaho, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Montana, Nebraska, Nevada, New Hampshire, New Mexico, North Carolina, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, Virginia, Washington, West Virginia, Wisconsin, and Wyoming. See license details by state.

How appraisers handle a shortage of sales

Each item below is a Fannie Mae or FHA appraisal rule for homes with few comparable sales nearby.

  • Fannie Mae requires at least three closed comparable sales, and your home can be a fourth comparable if it sold before.
  • Fannie Mae prefers sales from the last 12 months, but an older sale can be used when market conditions limited recent sales, and the appraiser must explain it.
  • For a rural home, Fannie Mae allows comparable sales a considerable distance away when they produce credible results and the appraiser explains why they were chosen.
  • On FHA, the appraiser must include at least three sales that settled no more than 12 months before the appraisal, and older sales can only be added as extra support.
  • On FHA, comparable sales are chosen for similar location and physical features, not for their sales price.
  • Under Fannie Mae, the appraiser may not create a comparable by combining a vacant land sale with the contract price of a home.
Single dark house on open land under a blue sky

Three closed sales required

Older sales can work

Farther sales in rural areas

FHA keeps a 12 month line

Listings add support

One appeal per appraisal

What Happens When There Are No Recent Comparable Sales?

A shortage of nearby sales does not by itself end the loan. Fannie Mae lets the appraiser widen the search in time or distance, and FHA lets the appraiser add older sales, each with an explanation in the report.

The appraiser compares your home with similar homes that sold. Fannie Mae requires at least three closed comparable sales. When few truly similar homes have sold, because the home is unusual or few homes sell in the area, the appraiser may use homes that are not truly comparable if they document the analysis and explain why. Fannie Mae also allows sales from competing neighborhoods, but the appraiser must not stretch the neighborhood boundaries to take them in. Distance to each sale is reported in miles with a direction, measured in a straight line.

FHA works a little differently. On FHA, the appraiser must include the most recent and relevant sales, preferably within the last six months, and at least three sales that settled no more than 12 months before the appraisal. In rural and slow markets, sales older than 12 months may be added as extra sales, with a thorough explanation of market conditions, supply and demand, and why recent sales are missing. A foreclosure transfer to a lender is not a valid comparable for an FHA loan. See our FHA loan page.

New subdivisions, condo projects and PUDs have their own rules. Under Fannie Mae, if your home is one of the first to sell, two pending sales in the project can stand in for one closed sale, plus at least three closed sales from outside it. In a new project of 2 to 20 units with no sales at all, sales from a competing project can be used. Fannie Mae accepts unique homes such as log homes and geodesic domes when the appraiser has enough information, but not when there is no evidence of market acceptance.

Modern house set among trees and rocks

Why choose Saxton when there are few comparable sales

This page is for buyers and homeowners whose home sits in a rural area, a new development, or a neighborhood where few homes sell.

We Compare Both Rule Sets

Fannie Mae can rely on older sales when the appraiser explains why, while FHA still needs three sales that settled within 12 months. We look at which set of rules fits the sales in your area.

Your Prior Sale Can Help

If the home sold before, Fannie Mae lets the appraiser use that sale as a fourth comparable or as supporting data. It adds to the three closed sales and does not replace them.

Listings And Contracts Count

Under Fannie Mae, pending contracts and current listings can be used as supporting data. On FHA, the appraiser must add support such as more sales, offerings, or offerings now under contract.

Foreclosure Sales Have Limits

Fannie Mae allows foreclosures and short sales as comparables when they are the best sales available, and the appraiser must consider condition and any stigma. On FHA, a foreclosure transfer to a lender is not a valid comparable.

Lenders Need A Review Process

Fannie Mae requires the lender to have a process for a borrower-initiated reconsideration of value. The request can include up to five comparable properties with an explanation, and the lender’s disclosure must make clear that only one borrower-initiated request is permitted per appraisal.

The Appraiser Stays Independent

On FHA, a mortgage broker may not select, manage or pay the appraiser, and the lender may not ask the appraiser for estimated values or comparable sales before the report is done. We do not try to steer the value.

Hear From Homeowners Like You

Frequently Asked Questions

Straight answers about appraisals when few homes have sold near yours.

Saxton Retail Mortgage does, through conventional loans that follow Fannie Mae rules and through FHA loans. Fannie Mae lets the appraiser use older sales or sales from competing neighborhoods when they explain why, while FHA needs at least three sales that settled within 12 months.

Fannie Mae prefers sales from the last 12 months, but the best sale is not always the newest: a nine month old sale with a time adjustment may be more suitable than a one month old sale that needs many adjustments. Older sales can be used if the appraiser explains why. On FHA, at least three sales must have settled within 12 months.

For a rural home, Fannie Mae allows sales a considerable distance away if they produce credible results and the appraiser explains why they were picked. If the appraiser goes outside the market area, they must explain why and make location adjustments if warranted.

Under Fannie Mae, two pending sales in the project can stand in for one closed sale, and the appraiser must also use at least three closed sales from outside the project. On FHA, the appraiser must select at least one sale from a competing subdivision and one from inside yours whenever possible.

Not to meet the minimum. Under Fannie Mae, the appraiser may not combine a vacant land sale with the contract price of a home to create a comparable. These transactions, often part of a construction-to-permanent loan, can be added as extra support with commentary.

It can be. Fannie Mae accepts unique homes such as earth houses, geodesic domes and log houses when the appraiser has enough information, and the comparable sales do not need to share the same design. If there is no evidence of market acceptance and no reliable value can be reached, the home is not acceptable under Fannie Mae.

Fannie Mae requires the lender on a Fannie Mae loan to have a process for a borrower-initiated reconsideration of value. The request can include up to five comparable properties, their data sources such as the MLS listing number, and an explanation, and only one borrower-initiated request is permitted per appraisal. On FHA, the underwriter may request a reconsideration of value when the appraiser did not consider information that was relevant on the effective date of the appraisal.

Find out what you qualify for

Tell us where the home is and what has sold nearby, and we will walk you through the appraisal rules that apply to your loan.

Get Pre-Qualified
Official program information
Written by Saxton Retail Mortgage · Reviewed by Saxton Mortgage, LLC, NMLS #1717191 · Last updated November 3, 2026

*Loan amounts, rates, terms, and down payment requirements are subject to credit approval, income and asset verification, and program eligibility. The appraiser, not Saxton Retail Mortgage, selects the comparable sales and develops the opinion of value. Not all applicants will qualify. Saxton Mortgage, LLC is an Equal Housing Lender.